vinylfanatics.com

**Big Star - Radio City: The Sound of Beautiful Failure**

There's something tragically poetic about a band called Big Star never becoming one, and nowhere is this cruel irony more apparent than on their devastating 1974 masterpiece, *Radio City*. This is the middle child of Big Star's holy trinity of albums—sandwiched between the pop perfection of *#1 Record* and the haunting fragmentation of *Third/Sister Lovers*—and it might just be their most essential statement.

The story begins in Memphis, where Alex Chilton had already tasted fame as the teenage voice behind The Box Tops' "The Letter." By 1971, he'd teamed up with Chris Bell, a fellow Memphis musician obsessed with The Beatles and The Byrds, to form Big Star. Their debut, *#1 Record*, was a stunning collection of power-pop gems that should have made them household names. Instead, distribution problems with their label Ardent Records meant the album barely registered outside of Memphis. Bell, devastated by the commercial failure and increasingly at odds with Chilton's vision, departed before *Radio City* was completed, leaving behind only his contributions to a few tracks.

What emerged from this creative turmoil was an album that perfectly captured the tension between pop ambition and artistic frustration. *Radio City* finds Chilton stepping fully into the spotlight, his voice carrying a new weight of melancholy and experience. The album's sound is looser and more ragged than its predecessor, trading some of the pristine harmonies for a grittier, more immediate energy that would later influence everyone from R.E.M. to The Replacements.

The opening track, "O My Soul," sets the tone with its driving rhythm and Chilton's increasingly urgent vocals, but it's "September Gurls" that stands as the album's crown jewel. Built around a simple but irresistible guitar riff and featuring one of the most perfect pop choruses ever committed to vinyl, the song is a masterclass in how to make heartbreak sound like celebration. The way Chilton stretches the word "September" into something both wistful and anthemic is pure magic—it's no wonder that bands like The Bangles would later turn it into a minor hit that Big Star themselves never achieved.

"Back of a Car" showcases the band's ability to craft intimate moments within their wall of jangly guitars, while "Daisy Glaze" demonstrates their knack for mysterious, atmospheric balladry. The album's other standout, "You Get What You Deserve," is a bitter pill wrapped in sweet harmonies, its title serving as both accusation and resignation. Throughout, drummer Jody Stephens provides the steady backbone that holds Chilton's increasingly experimental tendencies in check, while bassist Andy Hummel adds melodic counterpoints that elevate every song.

What makes *Radio City* so compelling is how it sounds like a band simultaneously reaching for the stars and watching them slip away. The production, handled by Chilton and engineer John Fry, has a lived-in quality that makes these songs feel like transmissions from a parallel universe where Big Star actually got the recognition they deserved. There's a looseness to tracks like "Mod Lang" and "Life Is White" that suggests a band learning to embrace imperfection as a creative tool.

The album's commercial failure was even more pronounced than its predecessor's, selling fewer than 10,000 copies upon release. This crushing disappointment would push Chilton toward the experimental extremes of *Third/Sister Lovers*, an album so raw and uncompromising it wouldn't see official release until 1978. That final album, recorded in a haze of alcohol and depression, stands as one of the most influential "lost" albums in rock history, its fractured beauty inspiring countless indie and alternative acts.

But it's *Radio City* that perhaps best captures what made Big Star special—their ability to find profound beauty in disappointment, to craft perfect pop songs about imperfect lives. In the decades since its release, the album has been rightfully recognized as a power-pop masterpiece, influencing generations of musicians who understood that sometimes the most powerful music comes from bands who never quite fit into their era.

Today, Big Star's legacy is secure, their influence traceable through the DNA of alternative rock. *Radio City* stands as testament to the idea that commercial failure doesn't diminish artistic achievement—sometimes it actually enhances it, creating art that resonates precisely because it captures the beautiful ache of unfulfilled dreams.