vinylfanatics.com

**Dinosaur Jr. - I Bet On Sky**
★★★★☆

After three decades of ear-splitting guitar heroics and enough volume to level small buildings, J Mascis and his merry band of noise merchants return with "I Bet On Sky," proving that some things never change – and thank God for that. This is Dinosaur Jr.'s third album since their unlikely reunion in 2005, and while it may not reach the towering heights of their holy trinity of classic releases, it's a surprisingly vital effort from a band that could easily coast on past glories.

To understand where "I Bet On Sky" fits in the Dinosaur Jr. universe, you need to appreciate the mountain they're climbing. Their 1987 breakthrough "You're Living All Over Me" essentially invented the template for '90s alternative rock before anyone knew what alternative rock was. It was a perfect storm of Mascis's guitar virtuosity, Lou Barlow's melodic bass lines, and Murph's thunderous drumming, all wrapped in a fuzz-drenched package that influenced everyone from Nirvana to Pavement. The album's centerpiece, "Little Fury Things," remains one of the most devastating guitar workouts ever committed to tape, while "Sludgefest" and "The Lung" showcased their ability to marry pop sensibilities with volcanic noise.

Then came 1993's "Where You Been," their major label masterpiece that should have made them superstars. Songs like "Start Choppin'" and "Out There" proved they could write radio-ready hooks without sacrificing their trademark sonic assault. The album found the perfect balance between accessibility and abrasion, with Mascis's guitar solos reaching new levels of transcendence. It was Dinosaur Jr. at their most focused and arguably their most powerful.

The third pillar of their legacy, 1994's "Without a Sound," saw them pushing even further into mainstream territory while maintaining their essential DNA. Tracks like "Feel the Pain" became MTV staples, but beneath the polish lay the same wounded romanticism and guitar worship that always defined their sound. These three albums established Dinosaur Jr. as one of the most important American rock bands of their generation, creating a blueprint that countless indie and alternative acts would follow.

Fast forward to 2012, and "I Bet On Sky" finds the reunited trio – Mascis, Barlow, and Murph – settling into a comfortable groove that recalls their mid-'90s peak without feeling like nostalgia. The album opens with "Don't Pretend You Didn't Know," a mid-tempo crusher that immediately establishes this isn't going to be a victory lap. Mascis's guitar tone remains gloriously thick and woolly, while his vocals maintain that distinctive mumbled vulnerability that made him indie rock's most unlikely frontman.

The album's strongest moments come when they lean into their strengths without overthinking things. "Watch the Corners" builds from a gentle acoustic opening into a typically explosive crescendo, showcasing their dynamic range. "Pierce the Morning Rain" finds Mascis in classic form, wrapping melancholy lyrics in layers of distortion and feedback. Meanwhile, "What Was That" demonstrates their continued ability to craft perfect three-minute pop songs disguised as noise rock epics.

Lou Barlow contributes two tracks – "Rude" and "Recognition" – that provide welcome textural variety while maintaining the album's cohesive feel. His more straightforward approach serves as an effective counterpoint to Mascis's guitar maximalism, and his presence adds emotional weight to the proceedings.

While "I Bet On Sky" doesn't break new ground, it doesn't need to. At this stage of their career, Dinosaur Jr. has earned the right to perfect their formula rather than reinvent it. The production, handled by the band themselves, strikes the right balance between clarity and grit, allowing each instrument space to breathe while maintaining their signature wall of sound.

The album's legacy lies not in revolutionary innovation but in proof of concept – that a band can reunite after bitter breakups and creative differences to create music that honors their past while justifying their present. In an era where reunion tours often feel like cynical cash grabs, "I Bet On Sky" stands as evidence that some musical partnerships are worth preserving.

Dinosaur Jr. may never again scale the peaks of their classic period, but "I Bet On Sky" proves they don't need to. Sometimes, being really good at what you do is enough.