vinylfanatics.com

When Lars Ulrich first floated the idea of Metallica performing with a full symphony orchestra, even the band's most devoted fans probably thought the drummer had finally lost his mind. After all, this was the same group that had spent the better part of two decades perfecting the art of sonic brutality, turning amplifiers up to eleven and making eardrums bleed in the name of heavy metal glory. The notion of James Hetfield's growling vocals and Kirk Hammett's blistering solos sharing space with violins and cellos seemed about as likely as finding a unicorn in a mosh pit.

Yet when Metallica took the stage at Berkeley's Community Theatre on April 21 and 22, 1999, alongside conductor Michael Kamen and the San Francisco Symphony, something magical happened. The resulting live album, simply titled "S&M," proved that sometimes the most unlikely partnerships create the most extraordinary art.

The genesis of this ambitious project can be traced back to Kamen himself, the classically trained composer who had already demonstrated his ability to bridge the gap between rock and orchestral music through his work on film scores and collaborations with artists like Pink Floyd and Eric Clapton. Kamen approached Metallica with the concept, and despite initial skepticism, the band was intrigued enough to give it a shot. What emerged was far more than a simple rock band playing with backing strings – it was a complete reimagining of Metallica's catalog through a symphonic lens.

Musically, "S&M" occupies a genre-defying space that's part heavy metal, part classical music, and entirely its own beast. The symphony doesn't merely accompany Metallica; it engages in a genuine dialogue with them. On tracks like "Master of Puppets," the orchestra's dramatic swells and intricate arrangements transform an already epic composition into something approaching operatic grandeur. The strings don't soften Metallica's edge – they sharpen it, adding layers of complexity and emotional depth that reveal new dimensions in songs fans thought they knew inside and out.

The album's crown jewel is undoubtedly "One," where the symphony's haunting melody lines perfectly complement the song's anti-war narrative. The orchestral arrangement amplifies the track's cinematic quality, turning it into a powerful statement that hits with the force of a sledgehammer wrapped in silk. "The Call of Ktulu," an instrumental piece that was practically begging for symphonic treatment, becomes an otherworldly journey that showcases both Metallica's compositional skills and the orchestra's technical prowess.

Equally impressive is "For Whom the Bell Tolls," where the symphony's dramatic punctuation transforms the song's already ominous atmosphere into something truly spine-tingling. The interplay between Cliff Burton's posthumous bass lines (performed by Jason Newsted) and the orchestra's low-end strings creates a sonic foundation so solid you could build a cathedral on it. Meanwhile, "Fuel" proves that even Metallica's more straightforward rockers benefit from orchestral enhancement, with the symphony adding a sense of urgency and momentum that makes the song feel like it's racing toward the apocalypse.

The album also features two Kamen compositions performed solely by the orchestra – "Ecstasy of Gold" and "A Call of Ktulu" – which serve as perfect bookends to the metal mayhem, demonstrating the symphony's ability to hold its own without the band's support.

Twenty-five years later, "S&M" stands as one of the most successful experiments in rock history. It spawned a sequel, "S&M²," in 2019, proving that the concept had serious staying power. More importantly, it opened the door for countless other metal and rock acts to explore orchestral collaborations, from Nightwish's symphonic metal epics to more recent projects by bands like Epica and Within Temptation.

The album's legacy extends beyond its influence on other artists. It demonstrated that heavy metal, often dismissed as simple or crude by classical music purists, possessed a sophistication and emotional depth that could stand alongside any art form. "S&M" didn't just prove that Metallica could play with an orchestra – it proved that they belonged there.

In an era when rock music often feels fragmented and searching for direction, "S&M" remains a towering achievement that reminds us of music's power to surprise, challenge, and transcend boundaries. Sometimes the craziest ideas turn out to be the most brilliant ones.