vinylfanatics.com

**Shack - H.M.S. Fable ★★★★☆**

In the grand pantheon of Liverpool's musical misfits and magnificent obsessives, few stories are as compelling as that of Mick and John Head's Shack. By the time H.M.S. Fable emerged in 1999, the brothers had already lived through enough rock'n'roll mythology to fill several lifetimes. From the ashes of their earlier incarnation as Pale Fountains – those post-punk romantics who promised so much in the early '80s before imploding spectacularly – Shack had already delivered the lost classic Zilch (recorded in 1988 but not released until 1991 after the master tapes were literally rescued from a burning studio), and the critically acclaimed but commercially ignored Waterpistol in 1995.

H.M.S. Fable finds the band – primarily the songwriting partnership of Michael Head and his brother John, along with various sympathetic collaborators – in reflective mood, crafting what amounts to a meditation on survival, both personal and artistic. The album's title suggests both journey and storytelling, and indeed this feels like a collection of parables from the margins, tales told by someone who has seen the music industry's promises turn to ash but somehow retained faith in the transformative power of a perfectly turned melody.

Musically, H.M.S. Fable sits comfortably in that peculiarly English tradition of psychedelic pop that stretches from The Kinks through The La's to later practitioners like Oasis, though Shack's approach is far more nuanced and literary than most. Michael Head's songwriting draws from the same well of Merseyside melancholy that produced "Waterloo Sunset" and "There She Goes," but his vision is more explicitly damaged, more aware of life's fundamental disappointments. The production, handled by Chris Allison, strikes an ideal balance between intimacy and grandeur, allowing space for both whispered confessions and moments of orchestral sweep.

The album opens with "Pull Together," a statement of intent that manages to be both defiant and fragile. Head's vocals, always his secret weapon, float over a bed of acoustic guitars and subtle strings, immediately establishing the album's emotional territory. It's followed by "Comedy," perhaps the record's finest moment, where a deceptively simple melody carries lyrics that cut straight to the bone: observational, bitter, but somehow still hopeful. The song exemplifies everything that makes Shack special – the ability to find beauty in mundane disappointment, to locate the universal in the painfully specific.

"Natalie's Party" continues this theme, a perfectly crafted piece of suburban psychedelia that recalls The Zombies at their most wistful, while "Since I Met You" strips things back to just voice and guitar, creating an intimacy that's almost uncomfortable. The album's centrepiece might be "Byrnes," a sprawling, ambitious piece that builds from humble beginnings into something approaching grandeur, showcasing the band's ability to think in broader canvases when the mood strikes.

Throughout, Michael Head's lyrics demonstrate a poet's eye for detail and a philosopher's preoccupation with meaning. These aren't songs about rock'n'roll mythology or romantic clichés, but rather careful examinations of how ordinary people navigate disappointment, find small moments of grace, and continue moving forward despite everything. It's adult music in the best sense – not because it's boring or overly serious, but because it grapples with adult concerns while maintaining a sense of wonder about the world.

The album's legacy has grown considerably in the years since its release. While it barely troubled the charts at the time – a fate that had become depressingly familiar for Shack – it has found its audience among those who prize substance over surface flash. Critics have increasingly recognized it as a lost classic of late-'90s British pop, and its influence can be heard in the work of bands like Elbow and later Radiohead.

H.M.S. Fable stands as proof that sometimes the most important music comes from the margins, created by artists who have learned to work outside the system's expectations. It's an album that rewards patience and repeated listening, revealing new layers with each encounter. In a decade dominated by Britpop bombast and manufactured rebellion, Shack offered something more valuable: genuine emotion, carefully crafted songs, and the hard-won wisdom that comes from refusing to give up on your art, no matter how many times the worl