vinylfanatics.com

**The Fiery Furnaces - Gallowsbird's Bark: A Phantasmagorical Journey Through Musical Madness**

★★★★☆

There's something deliciously unhinged about The Fiery Furnaces that makes you wonder if siblings Matthew and Eleanor Friedberger were raised on a steady diet of prog rock records and fever dreams. Their 2003 debut "Gallowsbird's Bark" arrived like a musical Molotov cocktail thrown through the window of indie rock's increasingly predictable house party, and nearly two decades later, it still sounds like nothing else before or since.

The Chicago-turned-Brooklyn duo had been kicking around the underground scene for a few years before unleashing this beast upon an unsuspecting world. Matthew, the musical architect behind the mayhem, had been crafting his labyrinthine compositions while Eleanor developed her chameleonic vocal style that could shift from sweet folk crooning to theatrical yelping within the span of a single verse. What emerged was an album that felt like stumbling into someone else's vivid nightmare – equal parts terrifying and exhilarating.

Musically, "Gallowsbird's Bark" defies easy categorization with the stubborn persistence of a cat refusing to be bathed. It's indie rock filtered through art-rock sensibilities, with detours into folk, blues, and experimental territory that would make Captain Beefheart nod approvingly from beyond the grave. The Friedbergers craft songs that feel less like traditional compositions and more like musical short stories, complete with narrative arcs, character development, and plot twists that leave listeners scrambling to keep up.

The album's crown jewel, "Tropical Ice-Land," unfolds like a fever dream travelogue, with Eleanor's vocals dancing between childlike wonder and worldly cynicism over Matthew's constantly shifting musical landscape. It's a seven-minute epic that somehow manages to feel both sprawling and intimate, like being trapped in an elevator with a very talented but slightly unhinged street performer. "Crystal Clear," meanwhile, showcases the band's ability to craft something approaching a conventional song structure while still maintaining their signature weirdness – it's their most accessible moment, which is saying something for a band that treats accessibility like a communicable disease.

"Evergreen" stands as perhaps their most emotionally direct statement, stripping away some of the usual theatrical flourishes to reveal the beating heart beneath all the artistic pretension. Eleanor's vocals here are genuinely moving, proving that beneath all the experimental window dressing lies genuine songwriting talent.

"Gallowsbird's Bark" would prove to be just the opening salvo in The Fiery Furnaces' campaign to confound and delight in equal measure. Their 2004 follow-up "Blueberry Boat" would push their maximalist tendencies even further, creating a double album's worth of material that played like a rock opera conceived by someone who'd never actually seen a rock opera but had it described to them by an unreliable narrator. It was brilliant and exhausting, like being force-fed cotton candy while riding a roller coaster designed by Salvador Dalí.

By 2005's "Rehearsing My Choir," the Friedbergers had achieved peak weirdness, crafting an entire album around their grandmother's reminiscences. It was either their masterpiece or their most indulgent folly, depending on your tolerance for experimental narrative structures and your feelings about elderly relatives monopolizing dinner conversation.

The band's legacy remains fascinatingly divisive. Critics either hailed them as visionary artists pushing rock music into uncharted territories or dismissed them as pretentious art-school dropouts making music primarily for other pretentious art-school dropouts. Both assessments contain kernels of truth, which is probably exactly how the Friedbergers prefer it.

In recent years, The Fiery Furnaces have continued their prolific output, though with somewhat diminished cultural impact. The indie rock landscape they helped shape has moved on to new forms of calculated weirdness, but "Gallowsbird's Bark" endures as a testament to what happens when genuine musical talent collides with fearless artistic ambition and a complete disregard for commercial considerations.

For those willing to surrender to its peculiar charms, "Gallowsbird's Bark" remains a thrilling reminder that rock music can still surprise, confound, and occasionally transcend its own limitations. It's not an easy listen, but the best art rarely is.