vinylfanatics.com

The Smashing Pumpkins had been dead and buried for six years when Billy Corgan decided to resurrect the corpse in 2007. What emerged wasn't quite the same beast that had dominated alternative rock in the '90s, but rather a curious hybrid that bore the familiar name while housing an entirely different soul. "Zeitgeist" – German for "spirit of the times" – arrived as both a statement of intent and a desperate grasp at relevance in a musical landscape that had largely moved on without them.

The album's existence stems from one of rock's most predictable comebacks. After The Smashing Pumpkins imploded in 2000 following the ambitious but bloated "Machina" double-album saga, Corgan spent the early 2000s exploring electronic music with Zwan and his solo work, ventures that satisfied neither critics nor the faithful. By 2006, nostalgia and financial necessity had aligned perfectly, prompting Corgan to dust off the Pumpkins moniker. The catch? Original members James Iha and D'arcy Wretzky wanted nothing to do with the reunion, leaving only drummer Jimmy Chamberlin to join Corgan in this musical necromancy.

What they conjured was an album that sounds exactly like what you'd expect from a middle-aged Billy Corgan trying to recapture his youth while simultaneously proving he's evolved. "Zeitgeist" is a deliberately heavy affair, abandoning much of the dreamy psychedelia and acoustic introspection that made classics like "Siamese Dream" and "Mellon Collie" so dynamic. Instead, Corgan and his hired guns – guitarist Jeff Schroeder, bassist Ginger Reyes, and the returning Chamberlin – deliver a relentlessly metallic sound that feels both nostalgic and oddly contemporary.

The album opens with "Doomsday Clock," a grinding industrial-metal anthem that immediately establishes this isn't your older sibling's Smashing Pumpkins. Corgan's voice, weathered but still capable of that distinctive nasal whine, delivers apocalyptic imagery over churning guitars and mechanical rhythms. It's effective in its brutality, even if it lacks the emotional complexity of the band's earlier work. Similarly, "7 Shades of Black" pounds away with the subtlety of a sledgehammer, its main virtue being Chamberlin's thunderous drumming, which remains as powerful as ever.

The album's crown jewel is undoubtedly "Tarantula," a track that manages to bridge the gap between classic Pumpkins and this heavier incarnation. Built around a hypnotic main riff and featuring some of Corgan's most engaging vocal melodies in years, it's the rare moment where the band's ambitions align perfectly with their execution. The song's success as a radio single proved that there was still an audience hungry for the Pumpkins' particular brand of melodic heaviness.

"That's the Way (My Love Is)" offers the album's most successful attempt at recapturing the band's gentler side, with Corgan's acoustic guitar work recalling the intimacy of songs like "Disarm." However, even here, the production feels oddly sterile, lacking the organic warmth that made the original lineup's quieter moments so affecting. "United States" sprawls across nearly ten minutes, showcasing Corgan's continued fascination with extended compositions, though it never quite justifies its length despite some genuinely beautiful passages.

The problem with "Zeitgeist" isn't that it's terrible – it's that it's competent in all the wrong ways. The performances are tight, the production is professional, and Corgan's songwriting, while not at his peak, contains flashes of his former brilliance. But the magic that made The Smashing Pumpkins special was never just about Billy Corgan's vision; it was about the creative tension between four distinct personalities. Without Iha's melodic counterpoint or even D'arcy's understated bass work, these songs feel like high-quality Smashing Pumpkins tribute band performances.

Today, "Zeitgeist" occupies a peculiar place in the band's catalog. It's neither beloved nor reviled, existing instead as a competent but ultimately unnecessary chapter in the Pumpkins story. The album sold respectably and reminded the world that Billy Corgan could still craft a decent song, but it failed to recapture the cultural lightning that made the band's